Winchester Super Target, Federal Top Gun, and Fiocchi Target Ammunition: A Comparison for Experienced Trap and Skeet Shooters

For serious trap and skeet shooters, having ammunition that not only delivers consistent performance but also tunes well to your shotgun can make all the difference on the range. Three popular lines—Winchester Super Target, Federal Top Gun, and Fiocchi Target—are designed to offer reliable patterning, consistent velocities, and affordability without compromising quality. In this article, we’ll explore the evolution, performance characteristics, and key differences among these three ammunition lines to help you make an informed decision about which is best suited to your shooting style and applications.

Winchester Super Target: Consistency and Reloadability

Winchester Super Target has long been a staple for shooters who demand uniform performance. Known for its consistent shot patterns and solid construction, Super Target is available in multiple gauges, including 12, 20, 28, and .410. Its design is optimized for disciplines such as trap, skeet, and sporting clays.

Key Features

• Shot Load:

  • Typically offered in 1 1/8‑ounce loads for 12 gauge.

  • Common shot sizes include #7.5 and #8, allowing for adjustments based on discipline and target distance.

• Velocity:

  • Standard muzzle velocity is around 1,200 fps, balancing recoil with effective target engagement.

• Component Quality:

  • Employs clean‑burning powders and reliable primers for uniform ignition.

  • Consistency in powder charges leads to predictable shot patterns.

• Reloading Potential:

  • The hulls are considered reloadable, appealing to shooters who customize loads for fine‑tuning pattern densities and velocities.

  • Many experienced reloaders compare Super Target favorably with Winchester’s premium AA line for its durability in reloading applications.

Field Performance

Winchester Super Target shells are praised for delivering tight, consistent patterns, making them a go‑to option for both practice and competitive shooting. Their balance of velocity and recoil ensures that pattern density remains stable across a variety of shotguns.

Federal Top Gun: Economical Reliability for High‑Volume Shooting

Federal’s Top Gun line is engineered to provide a reliable and economical option for target shooters who log high round counts. Like Super Target, Top Gun is available in various gauges and is designed to offer consistent performance for trap, skeet, and sporting clays.

Key Features

• Shot Load:

  • Commonly available in 1 1/8‑ounce loads for 12 gauge, with shot sizes typically in the #7.5 to #8 range.

• Velocity:

  • Delivers a muzzle velocity of approximately 1,200 fps, ensuring uniformity in target engagement.

• Component Quality:

  • Uses tightly controlled powder charges and reliable primers to ensure consistency shot after shot.

• Reloading Considerations:

  • While Top Gun offers excellent out‑of‑the‑box performance, its hulls are generally viewed as less ideal for reloading compared to higher‑end options like Federal’s Gold Medal line.

  • Its “use‑and‑dispose” nature appeals to shooters who prioritize consistent performance over reloading flexibility.

Field Performance

Federal Top Gun ammunition is widely regarded for its dependable patterning and consistency. Its budget‑friendly pricing and broad availability make it a popular choice for competitive shooters who need reliable ammo for high‑volume shooting without breaking the bank.

Fiocchi Target: Premium Performance for Precision Patterning

Fiocchi has carved out a reputation with its Target ammunition line, designed specifically for clay sports. Often referred to simply as “Fiocchi Target,” this line is a direct competitor to Winchester Super Target and Federal Top Gun, offering a premium yet affordable option for shooters looking for consistent performance and refined patterning.

Key Features

• Shot Load:

  • Fiocchi Target is available in 1 1/8‑ounce loads for 12 gauge, with shot sizes typically including #7.5 and #8.

  • The formulation is optimized for precise shot distribution, a key factor in disciplines like trap and skeet.

• Velocity:

  • Like its competitors, Fiocchi Target shells typically achieve muzzle velocities around 1,200 fps, ensuring a balance between effective range and manageable recoil.

• Component Quality:

  • Fiocchi is known for high‑quality components; Target ammunition uses premium powders and primers for consistent ignition and performance.

  • Shooters report that the resulting shot patterns are tight and reproducible, making Fiocchi Target a strong contender in competitive environments.

• Reloading and Consistency:

  • While not as reload‑friendly as some premium lines, Fiocchi Target’s hulls are engineered for consistency and are appreciated by shooters who favor out‑of‑the‑box performance.

  • Its formulation tends to deliver very predictable patterns, a critical factor for fine‑tuning your shotgun’s performance.

Field Performance

Experienced shooters often commend Fiocchi Target for its exceptional pattern consistency and overall reliability. Its premium components and refined manufacturing process ensure that the ammunition performs reliably across various shotguns, making it an attractive option for those seeking that extra edge in pattern tuning.

Deeper Dive: Understanding Shot Pattern Fundamentals

For experienced shooters, the ability to fine-tune your shotgun’s performance starts with a solid understanding of shot pattern fundamentals. The ultimate goal is to achieve the tightest, most consistent groupings possible.

Factors Affecting Shot Patterns

• Choke and Barrel Length:

  • The interaction between ammunition and your shotgun’s choke plays a critical role. A tighter choke can compress the shot string, improving pattern density, while a more open choke may produce a wider spread.

• Ammunition Formulation:

  • The quality of the powder and primer affects the uniformity of shot dispersal. Consistency in ignition leads to repeatable patterns, an area where Fiocchi Target’s premium formulations often shine.

• Environmental Conditions:

  • Variables such as temperature, humidity, and even altitude can influence how powder burns and shot patterns develop. Testing multiple loads under your typical shooting conditions can provide invaluable insights.

Reloading Considerations for Fine-Tuning

For shooters who reload, both Winchester Super Target and Federal Top Gun offer options, but they differ in reload-friendly characteristics. Super Target’s reloadable hulls may allow for more experimentation with powder charges and shot sizes, enabling you to dial in the perfect load for your specific shotgun setup. In contrast, while Federal Top Gun performs reliably, its hulls may not withstand as many reload cycles, nudging reloaders toward premium alternatives when long-term consistency is the goal.

Practical Field Testing and Adjustments

Beyond the lab, real-world testing is critical. Here are some practical tips for experienced shooters:

• Conduct Pattern Tests:

  • Fire a series of patterns with each ammunition type to observe consistency. Record group sizes and note any variations that might affect your overall performance.

• Adjust for Choke Compatibility:

  • Experiment with different choke tubes if available. The interaction between ammunition and choke can differ between brands, so minor adjustments may be necessary to optimize performance.

• Document Environmental Effects:

  • Over time, keep a log of how different ammunition behaves under various weather conditions. This data can help you choose the best load for specific shooting days or competitions.

• Evaluate Reloading Results:

  • If you’re reloading, compare how the ammunition holds up after multiple cycles. Consistency in the hulls and performance after reloading can indicate long-term value.

Comparative Analysis

Below is a side‑by‑side comparison of key attributes among Winchester Super Target, Federal Top Gun, and Fiocchi Target ammunition:

Feature	Winchester Super Target	Federal Top Gun	Fiocchi Target
Shot Load	1 1/8 oz (12 gauge); shot sizes: #7.5, #8	1 1/8 oz (12 gauge); shot sizes: #7.5, #8	1 1/8 oz (12 gauge); shot sizes: #7.5, #8
Muzzle Velocity	~1,200 fps	~1,200 fps	~1,200 fps
Component Quality	Clean‑burning powder, reliable primers; reloadable hulls	Tightly controlled powder and primers; less reload-friendly	Premium powders and primers for tight, consistent patterns
Reloading Potential	Good reload potential; compared favorably to Winchester AA	Generally “use‑and‑dispose” approach	Not as reload‑focused; valued for out‑of‑the‑box consistency
Cost and Availability	Budget‑friendly and widely available	Economical; ideal for high‑volume shooting	Affordable premium option with consistent performance
Target Applications	Trap, skeet, sporting clays; excellent pattern uniformity	Reliable for trap, skeet, and sporting clays	Precision patterning ideal for competitive trap and skeet

Final Thoughts

Winchester Super Target, Federal Top Gun, and Fiocchi Target all offer reliable, economical options for trap and skeet shooters, each with its unique strengths. Winchester Super Target is celebrated for its consistency and reloadability, Federal Top Gun for its dependable, budget‑friendly performance, and Fiocchi Target for its premium components and exceptional pattern consistency.

For experienced shooters looking to fine‑tune ammunition to their shotgun, the best approach is to test each line in your specific setup. Consider how the ammunition interacts with your choke, the consistency of your shot patterns, and your personal preferences regarding reloadability versus out‑of‑the‑box performance. Real-world testing under varying environmental conditions is key to making an informed decision. By documenting your results and adjusting your equipment accordingly, you’ll be well-equipped to choose the ammunition that maximizes your accuracy and confidence on the range.

Happy shooting, and may your chosen ammunition help you achieve consistent, tight patterns and elevate your performance every time!

Check out our ammo inventory and let us know if there's something you'd like that we don't have on the website or in stock. Our goal is to have everything you need so if we're lacking, say the word and we'll fix it!

If you found this informative, we invite you to sign up for email notifications of new blog articles.

#ShootingSports #Firearms #TargetShooting #GunCommunity #Shotgun #RangeShooting #Ammunition #GunLovers #ShotgunAmmo #AmmoReview #TrapShooting #SkeetShooting #SportingClays #GunTech #Reloading #GunReview #WinchesterAmmo #FederalAmmo #FiocchiTarget #GunTalk #MidwestShooting #IowaOutdoors #NebraskaHunting #SouthDakotaOutdoors #MinnesotaOutdoors #AmmoPerformance #PatternTuning #ShotgunSports #CompetitiveShooting #RangeTested