Understanding the differences between rimfire and centerfire cartridges is essential for choosing the right firearm, practicing proper maintenance, and ensuring safe shooting. In this guide, we’ll delve into the mechanics, applications, and advantages of each type of cartridge, explain why dry firing can be harmful (even for centerfire firearms), and discuss the role of snap caps in preserving firearm longevity.
What Are Rimfire and Centerfire Cartridges?
Rimfire Cartridges
Definition: Rimfire cartridges ignite when the firing pin strikes the rim at the base of the case. The priming compound is distributed within the rim, which acts as the ignition point.
Common Examples: .22 LR, .22 WMR, .17 HMR.
Design Characteristics:
Thin Case Walls: The case is constructed from lightweight materials to facilitate ignition when the rim is struck.
Non-Reloadable: Rimfire cases cannot be reused due to their thin construction.
Best Uses:
Plinking and recreational shooting.
Small game hunting.
Training new shooters due to low recoil and minimal noise.
Centerfire Cartridges
Definition: Centerfire cartridges ignite when the firing pin strikes a replaceable primer located at the center of the case base.
Common Examples: 9mm Luger, .223 Remington, .308 Winchester.
Design Characteristics:
Thicker Cases: Designed to withstand higher pressures, making them reloadable.
Replaceable Primer: A removable primer allows the case to be reused multiple times through reloading.
Best Uses:
Self-defense, hunting, and competitive shooting.
Long-range and large-game applications requiring higher energy and velocity.
Key Differences Between Rimfire and Centerfire Cartridges
Feature | Rimfire | Centerfire |
Ignition System | Priming compound in the rim | Primer in the center |
Pressure Tolerance | Low pressure | High pressure |
Durability | Fragile case | Robust case |
Reloading | Not reloadable | Cases can be reloaded |
Applications | Small calibers, low recoil | Broad range of calibers |
Cost | Generally cheaper | More expensive |
Why Dry Firing Can Be Harmful
Dry firing refers to pulling the trigger on an unloaded firearm, causing the firing pin or striker to strike without a cartridge in place. Its impact depends on the type of firearm:
Rimfire Firearms
Problem: The firing pin strikes the rim of the cartridge. Without a cartridge in place, the firing pin hits the edge of the chamber, potentially deforming or damaging both the firing pin and the chamber.
Consequence: Repeated dry firing can lead to:
Misaligned or broken firing pins.
Burrs or dents in the chamber that affect cartridge seating and ejection.
Centerfire Firearms
Why Dry Firing Is Less Harmful:
In centerfire firearms, the firing pin typically moves forward into an empty chamber when dry fired, avoiding direct contact with hard surfaces.
Most modern centerfire firearms are designed to tolerate dry firing during normal use.
Why It’s Still Not Ideal:
Repeated dry firing can cause wear or stress on the firing pin, striker, or firing pin spring over time, particularly in older designs or firearms with brittle firing pins.
Snap Caps: Why They’re Essential
Snap caps are inert training tools designed to mimic the shape and weight of live cartridges. They serve several purposes in maintaining and safely practicing with your firearm.
Benefits of Snap Caps:
Protects Firing Pins and Chambers:
In rimfire firearms, snap caps prevent the firing pin from striking the chamber, avoiding damage.
In centerfire firearms, snap caps absorb the impact of the firing pin, reducing wear.
Training and Practice:
Snap caps allow for safe dry fire practice, helping shooters improve trigger control, follow-through, and sight alignment.
Useful for malfunction drills, simulating misfires, or stovepipes.
Function Testing:
Snap caps let you safely test feeding, extraction, and ejection without the risk of using live ammunition.
Choosing Rimfire vs. Centerfire for New Shooters
Scenario | Rimfire | Centerfire |
Cost-Conscious Practice | Ideal for beginners due to low ammunition cost. | More expensive but provides real-world practice. |
Small Game Hunting | Excellent for small game (.22 LR, .22 WMR). | Overkill for small game; suited for larger animals. |
Training New Shooters | Low noise and recoil make rimfire perfect. | Higher recoil and noise may intimidate some. |
Self-Defense | Not recommended due to limited power. | Preferred choice for defensive applications. |
Additional Tips for New Shooters
Inspect Barrel Markings:
Look for stamped markings near the chamber or barrel to confirm the exact caliber your firearm is designed for (e.g., ".22 LR" or ".223 Rem").
Ensure ammunition matches these markings to avoid dangerous misfires or malfunctions.
Understand Ammunition Selection:
For rimfire: Start with standard velocity rounds for general use.
For centerfire: Match bullet type and weight to your intended application (e.g., hollow points for defense, FMJ for range practice).
Practice Safe Maintenance:
Use snap caps during dry fire training.
Regularly inspect firing pins and springs for signs of wear.
Start Small, Progress Gradually:
Begin with a rimfire firearm to build confidence and proficiency.
Transition to centerfire calibers as your skills improve.
The differences between rimfire and centerfire cartridges extend beyond their ignition systems, encompassing cost, application, and firearm maintenance requirements. While modern centerfire firearms can generally tolerate dry firing, using snap caps is a simple, effective way to protect your firearm and improve your training routine. In rimfire firearms, avoiding dry firing altogether is essential to prevent damage.
By understanding the mechanics and best practices for both cartridge types, new shooters can make informed choices, prolong the life of their firearms, and develop solid shooting fundamentals for a lifetime of safe and effective shooting.
Explore our selection of ammunition here. If there's something you'd like but don't see, let us know and we'll add it to our inventory.
Comments